|
|
SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Starting May 1—get up to 2,500 FREE listings* every month with an eBay Stores subscription
eBay has reduced the upfront cost to sell for Store sellers! With eBay’s new everyday rate plans, you get from up to 150 to 2,500 FREE listings* per month—no insertion fees, auction-style or fixed price—with an eBay Stores subscription. You pay a final value fee only when you sell! Plus, the final value fees for Stores have been streamlined to just 5 competitive category-based rates as low as 4%—and never more than 9%—regardless of how you sell.
Learn more about everything eBay Stores have to offer, then use the Fee Illustrator to find the best Store option for you! Watch this tutorial to learn how.
*Pay no insertion fees for your allotted free listings per calendar month. Optional fees, including advanced listing upgrades and supplemental service fees, still apply. Pay final value fees only when you sell. Motors Vehicles, Real Estate, Heavy Equipment, Concession Trailers & Carts, Imaging & Aesthetics Equipment and Commercial Printing Presses are excluded. 12 free pictures does not apply to Motors Vehicles listings. Terms are subject to change. Learn more.
|
|
SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 2, 2012 06:04 PM
|
I think June was the month I signed up for....
Anyway, there it is.
The soapbox is so slow, nobody even cares if there is moderation or not.  ... a tiny bit later, that very same day.
|
|
|
|
(1 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 5, 2012 05:48 PM
|
Well, we GOT our answer on the FBB! If you accidentally say "Hi" or "Sorry for the double post" or (God forbid) "The quote feature seems to be glitchy today" you get a vacation.
Everyone trying to find a way to answer questions without a slap has killed the board completely. They give us a choice of moties to use, but slap you if you use one.
Nice work!
Founding member of the Pack of Disgruntled Failures. 
|
|
|
|
(2 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 17, 2012 07:10 PM
|
I've recently found out (actually, I already knew it), that anything you say on the discussion board can get you booted.....anything.
Two reasons for that. 1) Someone who doesn't like you can report several of your posts within a short period of time, posts that in no way violate the rules and number 2) the Pinks won't even look at the posts before putting them all together and sanctioning you.
There could be a number 3 there too but, I doubt that's the cause. Some (and I did say "some") pinks are either young or just don't know how to read people at all, they simply don't know what they are doing. That, or they need the job and are seeing what they want to see in order to say, we're doing something to earn our money. Again, that stuff is doubtful but, possible.
Automation doesn't work on a discussion board, not the way Ebay uses it.
Also, you will get no help here on issues because the pinks know there is no excuse for what they do but Ebay is going to make them do it anyway. So, that coupled with the fact we are no longer stupid enough to buy spin, what would the point be?
That's why John has disappeared, the pinks and Griff and it ain't us that caused it.
One thing I've also noticed is, the boards did pretty well until John may have stirred thing up. Can't say for sure it was his fault but it sure got nasty around SC for awhile right after he came on board, then when every thing calmed down, and things were going just fine, he slaps a new, no OT rule on SC. No idea what that was about.
Anyway, at least no one is here insulting our intelligence anymore, gotta give me that.
I recently read that some Ebay workers feel we are a bunch of conspiracy theorists and maybe there are a few but, I think that's clearly understandable considering the circumstances. However, I think that is something they like to throw around as a defense and to help keep themselves in the dark over what's really happened to Ebay as a whole. They never bother thinking what has caused that issue. Some Ebay workers hide behind any little thing they see us doing wrong but refuse to see the big picture because the big picture is EBAY and how badly they treat people.......it's an undeniable fact.
Sorry if that was OT or a little bouncy on the subject matter but, just a few things I wanted to get said. 
|
|
|
|
(3 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 18, 2012 10:44 AM
|
Plant, just so you know, John is no longer in charge of the department that is responsible for these boards. See my page for frequently used eBay discussion board acronyms.
|
|
|
|
(4 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 18, 2012 02:43 PM
|
Thanks, Lucky. That's probably good for me, that way I ddin't make anyone too mad at me with that last post.
Did something happen of any interest, or did he just give up on us?
|
|
|
|
(5 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 18, 2012 02:45 PM
|
Oh, and was there ever an explanation as to why SC got the no OT axe?
|
|
|
|
(6 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 19, 2012 02:18 AM
|
, gotta give me that
Should have been, gotta give em' that
|
|
|
|
(7 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 19, 2012 08:50 AM
|
It seems like eBay just decided to move him somewhere else, and it had nothing to do with his posts here on the boards.
I emailed him when they banned OT on SC and, no, he didn't give any real explanation, other than to say problems on the boards often stemmed from OT comments, and that a lot of people told him they didn't feel welcome on the boards. He didn't respond when I replied that that didn't happen on SC.
I did call him out on his failings with us, and he admitted that I was right about a lot of it. Whatever. He turned out to be just like all the other eBay employees we've dealt with over the last few years - worthless. See my page for frequently used eBay discussion board acronyms.
|
|
|
|
(8 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 20, 2012 03:08 AM
|
Thanks for the update.
And what's worse than worthless is that he actually got my/our hopes up, even after we could see what was going on right off the bat. I guess wishful thinking can make the most cynical of posters not think straight.
From what you say, at least he learned something and has more of a grasp of reality than he did when he started..
I'd like to think his intentions were good and then reality crept in and ruined it all but, I don't know.
|
|
|
|
(9 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 20, 2012 09:41 AM
|
Intentions may have been noble but execution of realistic and sensible actions fell far short. Whether his brief time here was all a smokescreen by his handlers to keep us off-topic of what management was really doing remains to be seen.
Suffice to say there now is no longer any identifiable person within eBay that has anything to do with the boards. It still remains unknown if CG is only one person or several (I suspect the latter).
Our country's #1 export?
- Money! (think about it)
|
|
|
|
(10 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 20, 2012 11:07 AM
|
Plant, what bothers me the most is that John came here and worked so very hard to gain our trust. The phone calls, the sticking in through threads that were thousands of posts long, the continued assurances of how "passionate" he was about the community. He fought long and hard for our trust, and when he got it, he basically gave us the finger because it got hard. A real man, someone who was truly passionate about the boards would have, at the very least, come here and said he'd failed. If he had done that, I would still respect him. Now, not so much. See my page for frequently used eBay discussion board acronyms.
|
|
|
|
(11 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 20, 2012 05:30 PM
|
Hello old friends, it's about time you showed up!
I thought you had all abandoned this place.
As you can see, I didn't forget start my ASSIGNED thread.

I don't get slapped very often, but I know that many others still get slapped for silly reasons.
I still don't understand those permanent sanctions. How does someone get put into that black hole forever? It just doesn't make any sense to me. Bon mot boogie
|
|
|
|
(12 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 20, 2012 05:32 PM
|
We are still "allowed" to post OT threads... and we can go off on tangents on any thread.
Disagreements are still thought to be interpersonal disputes...which is really dumb. Bon mot boogie
|
|
|
|
(13 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 20, 2012 08:58 PM
|
I'm with you on that, Lucky. It was easy to see early on that though John may not have known it, he had the corporate attitude and was completely blind to our side of issues. Blind by choice too, that's just much easier to do than admit the company you've wanted to work for is simply not such a good company after all. If that is the case, we were taken in by Ebay too.
Anyway, that attitude, either leads him to believe he has no fault in the matter, it's all us or, he's just afraid to admit to anything here on the boards now because we are like a bunch of sharks waiting to feed on anything, justified sharks but, sharks none the less.
Your right TCM. I guess as long as there is no announcement saying we can't post OT's, we're fine there. I think they are just experimenting with that no OT thing anyway but, pizzing posters off by removing the OT's especially on a board where there were no substantial problems, just wasn't smart.
They say the OT ban will eventually be implemented everywhere, not sure if that was the truth or just something to say to help shield them from the flak of banning the OT's where they did.
The moderation there on SC is weird and of course, is not working out any better than before. Had a lot of posts pulled today but no slaps so, maybe they're trying but just don't know what to do because Ebay wants it done cheaply and they have no alternative but to automate and fake the moderation. You know, kind of like ebay fakes customer service. 
The only way to mod those boards is to mod them but in spite of our offering to help, doesn't look like that's going to happen.
|
|
|
|
(14 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 21, 2012 10:28 AM
|
If you want to talk about pizzing someone off, imagine my reaction when they announced no OT on SC, then locked ONLY PLU, and none of the other OT threads. PLU, for Pete's sake! If it was a person, it would be community personified. Pizzed doesn't even come close. See my page for frequently used eBay discussion board acronyms.
|
|
|
|
(15 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 21, 2012 06:09 PM
|
I never did wrap my head around the presentation that JohnB made that was on YouTube all about how eBay listened to the boards. That was just so far out there as to be in another galaxy.
The one good thing I have seen is Hilary, who pops in, showing that she at least is reading the boards, and she makes things happen or at least provides an intelligent comment. I try to thank her when I see her, but I'm sure I'll get a #8 for that next time 
The boards are slowing down again, after a definitive flurry last fall.
Yeah, obviously PLU is not a community value, but the seller and buyer calling each other out for 200 posts is allowed. A summary of said 200 posts was deemed OT.
Engrish anyone? Is the morale improving around here yet?
|
|
|
|
(16 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 21, 2012 10:23 PM
|
If you want to talk about pizzing someone off, imagine my reaction when they announced no OT on SC, then locked ONLY PLU, and none of the other OT threads. PLU, for Pete's sake! If it was a person, it would be community personified. Pizzed doesn't even come close.
That pizzed me off and I didn't really post on the thread. John even ok'd that thread from the start. I sometimes think things are done here just to show "We have control and you don't" That's not going to keep *anyone* in line, it only makes posters angry and makes things worse. Or that is their only purpose, to Pizz us all off.
What I'm trying to say is there simply was no good reason to pull that or any OT on SC, nothing was out of hand. And I'm sure it was for the sake of experimentation to see if they could quiet things down and save a buck on moderation but, people, by nature, don't like being experimented with and things like that cause more trouble than they could possibly prevent in the long run.
Bottom line, they are trying to run the boards like they do Ebay, with minimal effort and all automation. Seems like they'd learn, it doesn't work there and it won't work here.
Burns, "another galaxy" kind of explains a lot of what goes on around here.
|
|
|
|
(17 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 22, 2012 05:25 AM
|
plant1here2 wrote:
Anyway, that attitude, either leads him to believe he has no fault in the matter, it's all us or, he's just afraid to admit to anything here on the boards now because we are like a bunch of sharks waiting to feed on anything, justified sharks but, sharks none the less.
Your right TCM. I guess as long as there is no announcement saying we can't post OT's, we're fine there. I think they are just experimenting with that no OT thing anyway but, pizzing posters off by removing the OT's especially on a board where there were no substantial problems, just wasn't smart.
They say the OT ban will eventually be implemented everywhere, not sure if that was the truth or just something to say to help shield them from the flak of banning the OT's where they did.
The moderation there on SC is weird and of course, is not working out any better than before. Had a lot of posts pulled today but no slaps so, maybe they're trying but just don't know what to do because Ebay wants it done cheaply and they have no alternative but to automate and fake the moderation. You know, kind of like ebay fakes customer service. 
The only way to mod those boards is to mod them but in spite of our offering to help, doesn't look like that's going to happen.

We must be moving up the food chain as I recall being referred to as a herd of cats...and John the cat herder.
As far as a corporate ban on OT, I said so many times that OT itself is not nor never was the root of moderation issues and that on some boards more than one concurrent OT thread seems to work fine. There are a few boards that work like (or better than in my opinion) the retired chats and also since they do offer real help and direction illustrate why silent neighborhoods/gruops get the boot.
There has been and still is a "limititation" per policy on only one OT thread per board but certainly that limit gets overlooked selectively, as I suggested, on boards where it isn't a problem.
Examples of OT thread topics allowed (and even pinned without asking)
- memberID need our prayers
- memberID has passed
- what does anyone know about woodstoves (in motors board) (although we did discuss charcoal burners on war-time vehicles in the Pacific which made it on-topic)
- name that band (in music - in true sense it is not off-topic as music is topic but it is OverTime, and fun)
In EBM we many times "make" a thread On Topic by simplified theory of relativity. An example. I went to the store in my car to pick up paint for the kitchen.
Bottom line if OT simply gets scrubbed on certan boards without additional penalty then life continues on. If penalties are handed out when a post is not otherwise egregious but simply OT then life is not good. Our country's #1 export?
- Money! (think about it)
|
|
|
|
(18 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 22, 2012 06:03 AM
|
Examples of OT thread topics allowed (and even pinned without asking)
Now that was the good ol' days. the days when everyone was relaxed and worked together, we had no reason to do otherwise. Everyone was happy.
Maybe the pinks are trying to punish is for being angry with Ebay and they somehow have managed to surmise this is all our fault.
OT's here have always been nothing but a good thing. One thinks all kinds of stuff when someone does something as odd as getting rid of one of the almost non existent things that make people happy around here so, I have to wonder if they actually think we will calm down with the Ebay bashing with expectations of getting OT's back?
Yep, sounds crazy but around here you never know. All they'll do is make things worse, I mean they just gave folks something else to bash.
That or maybe the purpose is to get rid of some of the outspoken regulars? You know, instead of outright booting them, treat them like the sellers and make things to where they will want to leave on there own? Make things more boring?
Gotta say, some of these people are so angry with Ebay, the harder they try to get rid of them the more they will want to stay.
Once again, we didn't start the fire, Ebay did and it's up to Ebay to put it out.
|
|
|
|
(19 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 22, 2012 06:09 AM
|
We must be moving up the food chain as I recall being referred to as a herd of cats...and John the cat herder.
How bout Catsharks? Now that sounds like a force to be reckoned with.
|
|
|
|
(20 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 22, 2012 09:37 AM
|
Mudsharks maybe, any realatio to mudpuppies? Certainly NOT bottom feeding catfish.  Our country's #1 export?
- Money! (think about it)
|
|
|
|
(21 of 21)
Re: SON of Policy and Moderation - 13+ Months Later and Yet ..... No Answers??
Jun 23, 2012 08:18 AM
|
I meant to say that OT is fine on the soapbox.
In saying that, they have culled our board down to 4 pages.
It had over 200 pages last year.
The soapbox moves at a very slow crawl now. Bon mot boogie
|
|
|